If the software in a vending machine or an automated store fails and causes harm, who is liable? Under the new European product liability directive, software becomes a product, just like the machine. Member States have until 9 December 2026 to transpose it, and anyone running third-party software should already know where each responsibility ends.
What changes on 9 December
Directive (EU) 2024/2853 on liability for defective products gives Member States until 9 December 2026 to transpose it. It applies to products placed on the market or put into service after 9 December 2026 (Art. 2.1).
The core change is that the definition of product expressly includes software. Free and open-source software that is not developed or supplied in the course of a commercial activity stays outside. And beyond the manufacturer, liability can reach importers, manufacturers of interconnected components that cause the defect and, in certain cases, online platforms.
Compensable harm covers death or personal injury (including medically recognised psychological harm), damage to property, and the destruction or corruption of data not used for professional purposes, according to the official EUR-Lex summary and law-firm notes such as Hogan Lovells. Damage to the defective product itself and professional data are excluded, as are goods used exclusively for professional purposes; only natural persons can claim (Arts. 5 and 6).
What weighs most in practice is evidence. A defect is presumed if the defendant fails to disclose relevant evidence in its possession, if it breaches mandatory safety requirements, or if the harm is caused by an obvious malfunction of the product. For latent personal injury the long-stop period is 25 years, and where there is a “substantial modification” it runs from when the product is placed on the market with that modification. The Directive defines it (Art. 4.18) and accepts that an update can be one (recital 39); the judge will decide in each case.
In Spain the current rules are Law 22/1994, now part of Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007. As of 15 November 2026 we have not found a published Spanish transposition text. I am not saying none exists, only that we have not found it.
What it means in a store without staff
An automated store runs layers of software that can come from different suppliers: the logic of each machine, the one that handles the sale and the screen, the payment gateway. When everything works, nobody asks where one ends and the next begins.
uNobo Connect is the operating system for automated 24/7 retail in our partner network. As I wrote in uNobo Connect is not an app, it runs on machines from TCN, Vendlife, EasyTouch, Jofemar, Necta and Bianchi, connecting through the MDB 4.x bus or the manufacturer’s API or SDK. The hardware controller remains the manufacturer’s. Our licence is per machine, with no commission on sales.
That architecture shows what matters here: in a store with machines from different manufacturers, there are layers of software from different suppliers. Before the injured party they can be jointly liable (Art. 12) and then share what was paid among themselves (Art. 14). And software updates after the sale raise a question that is resolved case by case: whether an update counts as a “substantial modification”, and with what consequences.
What we do not know yet
We do not know how the directive will apply to a vending machine or to a specific 24-hour store. What I write is our reading, not a court ruling. We have not done a legal analysis of any case either, and this article is not legal advice: if you operate in this sector, ask your lawyer how it affects your contracts.
Three questions for your software supplier
- How do we split by contract whatever has to be paid? Before the injured party, the contract does not limit liability (Art. 15).?
- Where exactly does your code end and the machine manufacturer’s controller begin?
- What technical records do you keep and can you produce if a judge or an expert asks? With the presumption of defect, being unable to disclose evidence is a risk in itself.
Better to have all three answers in writing before they are needed.
Román Suárez, Founder of Bonobo Services OÜ
Frequently asked questions
Does the directive cover damage to the defective product itself? No. Damage to the product itself and professionally used data are excluded, as are goods used exclusively for professional purposes; only natural persons can claim (Arts. 5 and 6).
Does it affect open-source software? Free and open-source software that is not developed or supplied in the course of a commercial activity is excluded.
What about machines that are already installed? It applies to products placed on the market or put into service after 9 December 2026. Whether a later update is a substantial modification is resolved case by case.